Price Guide App
Sign up

#1

1916-Buffalo-Nickel-DDO-AU50
  • 1916 Double Die Obverse (DDO)
  • By far the most valuable Buffalo Nickel is the 1916 DDO. Less than 200 have been certified by PCGS over the years, with the top grade being MS64. Top grades can sell for $250,000+ making it one of the most valuable coins in the world.
  • Very Rare & Valuable
Find One For Sale

#2

1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel
  • 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel
  • While the 1916 DDO is like finding a needle in a hay stack, the 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel can be found if you're lucky enough. PCGS has graded over 1,500 of these coins, making them rare, but not mega-rare. The top grade is MS66 and those can sell for $500,000 or more.
Find One For Sale

#3

1936-D 3-1/2 Legs Buffalo Nickel
  • 1936-D 3-1/2 Legs Buffalo Nickel
  • These Buffalo Nickels are very rare, and almost impossible to find in anything but poor condition. The highest grade on PCGS is MS62 and less than 300 have been graded. Consider yourself lucky if you find one of these coins. The highest grade (MS62) can sell for over $11,000.
Find One For Sale

#4

1926-S Buffalo Nickel
  • 1926-S Buffalo Nickel
  • In low-grade condition (XF40 and below) these Buffalo Nickels aren't worth much more than 1915-S, 1914-D and others. However in higher grade condition (MS60 and higher) these 1926-S Buffalo Nickels are highly collectible. The top grade is MS65 and those can sell for over $100,000.
Find One For Sale

#5

1935 Double Die Reverse Buffalo Nickel
  • 1935 Double Die Reverse
  • Very rare find in any condition. Mint-State condition and above can be very valuable, as less than 500 have been certified & graded by PCGS over the years. The top grade in existence is MS65 and those coins sell for $30,000 or more.
Find One For Sale

#6

1924-S Buffalo Nickel
  • 1924-S Buffalo Nickel
  • While this is a rare find, not nearly as rare as some of the other Buffalo Nickels that make the list - so it's a good idea to look carefully to see if you have this one. Over 1,500 of these coins have been graded & certified by PCGS. Even lower-end grades like XF40 are worth over $1,000 - and the highest grade (MS66) can sell for over $40,000.
Find One For Sale

#7

1914-3 Buffalo Nickel
  • 1914/3 Buffalo Nickel
  • Consider yourself very lucky if you find one a 1914/3 Buffalo Nickel in a stack of grandpa's coins. These are extremely rare, with only about 100 ever being certified & graded by PCGS. The top grade is MS66 and those sell for over $75,000. Lower-end grades like XF40 can sell for over $1,200.
Find One For Sale

#8

1937-D 3 Legs Buffalo Nickel
  • 1937-D 3 Legs Buffalo Nickel
  • The three leg variation of the 1937-D Buffalo Nickel is actually not all that rare in comparison to other Buffalo Nickels. Over 8,700 have been graded & certified by PCGS, which is one of the highest number in the Buffalo Nickel series. Even lower-end grades are worth quite a bit, with XF40's worth more than $650. The top grade is MS66 and those can sell for more than $63,000.
Find One For Sale

#9

1921-S Buffalo Nickel
  • 1921-S Buffalo Nickel
  • The 1921-S is a valuable Buffalo Nickel, but not particularly hard one to find. Lower-end grades like F12 can be worth about $200. Higher end grades like MS66 are worth close to $20,000.
Find One For Sale

#10

1927-S Buffalo Nickel
  • 1927-S Buffalo Nickel
  • Many other Buffalo Nickels could make the #10 spot on our list, but the 1927-S is a desirable Buffalo Nickel to add to any collection. Lower-end grades have been trending up in value, but are affordable. Top-end grades like MS66 can be worth more than $80,000.
Find One For Sale

Want to know what the most valuable your Buffalo Nickels are? Above is a list that keeps track of the values based on PCGS & NGC Graded coins.

Buffalo Nickel Information
Buffalo Nickel Price Guide
Updated Daily

Find out how much your Buffalo Nickel Coins are worth!

Updated With 2018 Values
Top 10 Most Valuable Buffalo Nickels
Do You Have One?

These are the most valuable & collectible Buffalo Nickels in existence.

Updated With 2018 Values
Buffalo Nickel Grading Scale
What grade is your coin?

Compare your coins with certified graded Buffalo Nickels

VG10 - Mint State 68
Top Selling Nickels
Updated 1 days ago

From Buffalo Nickels to Jefferson's they are all collectible.

Updated With 2018 Values


Top Selling Coins Lists:
Top Selling Gold Coins
Updated 3 days ago

Find out how much your gold coins are worth!

Updated With 2018 Values
Top Selling Silver Coins
Updated 2 days ago

From Silver Eagles to Silver Morgan's - Find out how much they are worth here.

Updated With 2018 Values
Top Selling Pennies
Updated 1 days ago

The most popular coins to collect are pennies - and they are valueable!

Updated With 2018 Values
Top Selling Nickels
Updated 1 days ago

From Buffalo Nickels to Jefferson's they are all collectible.

Updated With 2018 Values




Trading Card Price Guide Comic Book Price Guide Hot Wheels Price Guide Old Coins Price Guide