| 1 | | 1965 Topps | 122 | Joe Namath | PSA 8.5 | $92,433.00 | July 2016 |
| 2 | | 1958 Topps | 62 | Jim Brown | PSA 8.5 | $84,800.00 | July 2016 |
| 3 | | 1998 Playoff Contenders | 87 | Peyton Manning | PSA 10 | $35,105.00 | April 2016 |
| 4 | | 1948 Leaf | 1 | Sid Luckman | PSA 8 | $35,100.00 | July 2016 |
| 5 | | 1965 Topps | 122 | Joe Namath | PSA 8 | $31,201.00 | October 2016 |
| 6 | | 2000 Playoff Contenders | 144 | Tom Brady | PSA 10 | $30,300.00 | May 2016 |
| 7 | | 1971 Topps | 156 | Terry Bradshaw | PSA 9 | $28,108.00 | July 2016 |
| 8 | | 1958 Topps | 62 | Jim Brown | PSA 8 | $26,988.00 | October 2016 |
| 9 | | 1957 Topps | 138 | Johnny Unitas | PSA 8 | $25,410.00 | June 2016 |
| 10 | | 2000 Playoff Contenders Championship Parallel | 144 | Tom Brady | BGS 9 | $24,329.00 | June 2016 |
| 11 | | 2000 Upper Deck SP Authentic | 118 | Tom Brady | BGS 10 | $23,901.00 | June 2016 |
| 12 | | 1971 Topps | 156 | Terry Bradshaw | PSA 9 | $21,700.00 | September 2016 |
| 13 | | 1958 Topps | 66 | Bart Starr | PSA 10 | $21,600.00 | July 2016 |
| 14 | | 1958 Topps | 62 | Jim Brown | PSA 8 | $21,212.00 | September 2016 |
| 15 | | 1957 Topps | 151 | Paul Hornung | PSA 9 | $19,600.00 | October 2016 |
| 16 | | 1986 Topps | 374 | Steve Young | PSA 10 | $18,250.00 | January 2016 |
| 17 | | 1957 Topps | 138 | Johnny Unitas | PSA 8 | $18,100.00 | June 2016 |
| 18 | | 1981 Topps | 216 | Joe Montana | PSA 10 | $17,900.00 | October 2016 |
| 19 | | 1972 Topps | 200 | Roger Staubach | PSA 9 | $17,766.00 | June 2016 |
| 20 | | 1957 Topps | 85 | Dick Lane | PSA 9 | $17,300.00 | February 2016 |
| 21 | | 1998 Playoff Contenders | 87 | Peyton Manning | PSA 9 | $17,098.00 | October 2016 |
| 22 | | 1950 Bowman | 45 | Otto Graham | PSA 9 | $16,500.00 | April 2016 |
| 23 | | 1948 Leaf | 6 | Bobby Layne | PSA 8 | $15,101.00 | September 2016 |
| 24 | | 1976 Topps | 148 | Walter Payton | PSA 10 | $15,100.00 | April 2016 |
| 25 | | 1933 Goudey Sport Kings | 4 | Red Grange | PSA 8 | $15,030.00 | September 2016 |
| 26 | | 1956 Topps | 71 | Stan Jones | PSA 9 | $15,000.00 | June 2016 |
| 27 | | 2000 Playoff Contenders | | Tom Brady | BGS 9.5 | $14,600.00 | October 2016 |
| 28 | | 1978 Topps | 315 | Tony Dorsett | PSA 10 | $14,005.00 | October 2016 |
| 29 | | 1957 Topps | 151 | Paul Hornung | PSA 8.5 | $14,000.00 | October 2016 |
| 30 | | 1959 Topps | 140 | Bobby Mitchell | PSA 10 | $13,431.00 | October 2016 |
| 31 | | 1965 Topps | 122 | Joe Namath | PSA 7.5 | $13,400.00 | September 2016 |
| 32 | | 1965 Topps | 133 | Fred Biletnikoff | PSA 9 | $13,101.00 | July 2016 |
| 33 | | 1972 Topps | 200 | Roger Staubach | PSA 9 | $13,100.00 | October 2016 |
| 34 | | 1957 Topps | 85 | Dick Lane | PSA 8.5 | $13,100.00 | June 2016 |
| 35 | | 2000 Upper Deck SP Authentic | 118 | Tom Brady | PSA 10 | $12,700.00 | September 2016 |
| 36 | | 1986 Topps | 161 | Jerry Rice | PSA 10 | $12,500.00 | September 2016 |
| 37 | | 1971 Topps | 245 | Joe Greene | PSA 9 | $12,321.00 | September 2016 |
| 38 | | 1984 Topps USFL | 52 | Steve Young | PSA 10 | $12,100.00 | March 2016 |
| 39 | | 2000 Upper Deck SP Authentic | 118 | Tom Brady | BGS 9.5 | $12,000.00 | October 2016 |
| 40 | | 1965 Topps | 122 | Joe Namath | PSA 7 | $10,699.00 | October 2016 |
| 41 | | 1935 National Chicle | 34 | Bronco Nagurski | PSA 4 | $10,000.00 | February 2016 |